What Should You Consider Before Rolling Over a 401(k)?

You leave a job.

A few weeks later, one piece of your financial life is still sitting behind: your 401(k).

That is usually when the advice starts.

“Roll it over.”

“Move it into an IRA.”

“Consolidate everything.”

But before moving potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars, there is a better question:

What exactly gets better if you move it?

If you cannot answer that yet, you probably have more homework to do.

Start with what you already own

Log in to the old plan.

Do not look only at the balance.

Look at the investments.

Look at the fees.

Look at the services.

Look at the withdrawal rules.

Look at the features you may lose if the account moves.

Most rollover decisions become clearer when you stop thinking of the old 401(k) as “an old account” and start treating it as one option among several.

Then compare the new option

Suppose you are considering an IRA.

What would actually change?

Would you have more investment choices?

Probably.

Would you use them?

Maybe.

Would the account cost more or less?

That depends.

Would you gain advisory services?

Would you lose plan-specific features?

Those questions are much more useful than assuming an IRA is automatically an upgrade.

The fee comparison can be surprising

People often assume workplace plans are expensive.

Sometimes they are.

Sometimes the opposite is true.

Large employer plans can occasionally have access to investment pricing that is difficult to replicate elsewhere.

On the other hand, some plans carry administrative expenses that may no longer make sense for you.

You need the actual numbers.

Not assumptions.

Convenience is valuable – but it is not everything

Having five retirement accounts at four different institutions is annoying.

Consolidation can make financial life easier.

One login.

One statement.

One portfolio to monitor.

But simplicity is only one factor.

If you consolidate, you should understand what you are gaining and what you are giving up.

Ask one question before signing anything

Why am I moving this money?

A good answer might be:

“I want professional management.”

“I want to simplify my accounts.”

“I need investment choices that are not available in the plan.”

“I am building a retirement withdrawal strategy.”

A weak answer is:

“Because I thought I was supposed to.”

A rollover should solve a problem.

If you cannot identify the problem, there may be no reason to rush.

Advertising

Newsletter SignUp

Subscribe to our newsletter to get latest news, popular news and exclusive updates.