A Practical 401(k) Plan Review Checklist for Employers

Payroll runs every two weeks.

Employees contribute.

The 401(k) provider sends statements.

Nobody is complaining.

So everything must be fine, right?

Maybe.

But retirement plans have a habit of becoming “background systems.”

They keep running while the company changes around them.

More employees.

Higher payroll.

Different owners.

Different vendors.

More money inside the plan.

And sometimes the plan receives a serious review only when someone discovers a problem.

A better approach is to ask a few questions before there is a reason to panic.

Can someone explain who does what?

Ask the business owner:

Who handles the 401(k)?

The answer is often a company name.

That is not quite enough.

Your plan may involve:

A recordkeeper.

A third-party administrator.

An advisor.

Payroll.

A custodian.

Internal HR or finance staff.

If something goes wrong, who owns the task?

That should be clear before a problem occurs.

Do you know what the plan costs?

Not “approximately.”

Actually.

How much does the recordkeeper charge?

What are the investment expenses?

What does the advisor charge?

Are employees paying some expenses through their accounts?

Are there additional administrative fees?

If the answer requires twenty minutes of searching through statements, that itself tells you something.

Are employees using the benefit?

A company can spend significant money offering a retirement plan that employees barely understand.

Look at participation.

Look at contribution levels.

Look at whether employees are receiving the available match.

Then ask why.

Sometimes a better retirement benefit starts with better communication, not a new plan.

When was the investment menu last reviewed?

This is not about changing funds every year.

It is about knowing why the current choices are there.

Who selected them?

Who monitors them?

What process is used?

Can that process be documented?

And then there is the paperwork nobody wants to think about

Eligibility.

Contribution timing.

Beneficiary records.

Plan notices.

Form 5500.

Fidelity bond information.

These are rarely the exciting parts of a 401(k).

They are still part of running one.

A useful challenge for business owners

Ask someone responsible for the plan to answer twelve basic questions without calling a provider.

If they cannot, that does not automatically mean the plan is bad.

It may simply mean it is time for a proper review.

Advertising

Newsletter SignUp

Subscribe to our newsletter to get latest news, popular news and exclusive updates.